Nearly Three Decades Later, the Suspicions of Two Women Led to the Arrest of Mandy Starvick’s Killer

They had suspicions about the killer from the beginning. Yet, they were afraid to make accusations without not knowing for sure.

At the age of 18, Mandy Starwick was raped and murdered.

On a sunny day in June 2013, two mothers decided to take their young children to the Birch Bay Waterslide in Washington. While the children were having fun, the mothers were chit-chatting.

They were in the same high school, but barely knew each other at the time. There was a tragedy that happened in 1989 involving another schoolgirl from their high school.

While chit-chatting, one woman brought up the topic. After over two decades, they felt it was safe to say their suspect’s name out loud. Surprisingly, they both said the same name.

Because both of them had somewhat unpleasant experiences involving that person. Finally, they decided to report him to the police.

It marked a major breakthrough in Mandy Starvick’s decades-old rape and murder case.

Mandy Starvick’s Final Jogging

Mandy’s family was originally from Alaska. After her parents divorced, Mandy’s mother brought her and her siblings to Acme, a small town in Whatcom County, Washington.

Mandy was a colorful athletic student at her school. She participated in softball, basketball, riding horseback, and running track. Family and friends described her as cheerful and vibrant.

Mandy was just 18 years old in 1989 and a freshman at Central Washington University. She returned home over Thanksgiving weekend. The day after Thanksgiving, she jogged with the family dog ​​in the evening.

Mandy’s mother usually biked with Mandy jogging, but she didn’t that day. Mandy’s brother, who was on the way, saw Mandy running towards the house with the dog. Two hours later the dog returned home without Mandy.

Her mother panicked and called everyone Mandy knew to find her. When Mandy was nowhere to be seen, her mother reported her missing to the police.